The Historic Shenzhen Trilateral

The highly anticipated meeting in Shenzhen between the leaders of the United States, the Russian Federation, and the People’s Republic of China concluded with a joint document titled “Declaration Towards Peace.” This development gives the summit a significance that extends beyond the personal interaction between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin.

The assessments reached and the political commitments made in this Declaration—as well as its overall content—will derive their true importance from how they are implemented.

1. As permanent members of the United Nations Security Council, China, Russia, and the United States committed to reforming the UN, ensuring that the organisation can respond more effectively to global challenges and remain true to its founding mission of maintaining international peace and security.

2. All three nations plan to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations. They reaffirmed the importance of ensuring stable energy flows.

3. The three heads of state acknowledged that the principle of state consent and respect for the immunities of state officials are of paramount importance, and agreed that the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.

4. The three heads of state reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. All three countries will engage in dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.

The declaration supports UN reform. In the economic sphere, it expresses an intention to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products. A significant political portion is dedicated to the immunity of state officials and the activities of the International Criminal Court. The text concludes with a commitment to dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons. It can now be said that a written, mutually accepted document on cooperation exists, although it sets no specific timeframe and does not define a detailed implementation mechanism. The most reasonable conclusion is that Shenzhen produced an initial political agreement, the value of which will depend on the work that follows and the diplomatic and political actions needed to overcome the difficulties that may (in all likelihood) arise in the future. Nevertheless, it is worth noting that the meeting and the joint statement carry substantial significance in multiple respects—just as significant as the absence of the EU, France, or the United Kingdom from this gathering.

THE POLITICAL GAIN FROM THE MEETING WAS IMMEDIATE

For Putin, the very fact that the meeting took place was valuable. The Russian President appeared alongside the U.S. President, with China as the host, at a table where responsibility for global security was being discussed. During their private meeting, Trump referred to him as a “friend.” This treatment serves the Kremlin’s effort to portray Russia as a power without which international problems cannot be solved. The boost to its image is clear, though it does not constitute evidence of any American concessions to Russian demands. For the Kremlin, creating the impression that its political isolation is easing may be an achievement in itself. How far this benefit extends will depend on the decisions Washington makes moving forward.

Xi benefited from his position as host. Shenzhen placed China at the centre of a diplomatic event that drew global attention. The Chinese president proposed regular contacts between the leaderships, as well as communication mechanisms for crisis situations. Such a proposal allows Beijing to present itself as a proponent of stability at a time when its relations with Washington remain strained by strategic competition. It remains unclear whether this proposal evolved into a joint commitment.

For his part, Trump framed the meeting as an expression of an approach that prioritises direct talks with adversaries. However, the challenge arises when personal rapport must translate into shifts in state policy. While a warm relationship between leaders may facilitate communication, it does not clarify what each side is prepared to concede.

In any case—consistent with the tradition of such past encounters—both presidents can return to their respective offices with a narrative that appeals to their own domestic audiences, even though the disagreements that necessitated the meeting have not necessarily vanished. One development worthy of note is the prominence given to Ukraine during the meeting and in subsequent public statements. Prior to the summit, American officials had indicated that the war was not expected to be part of the trilateral format. In Shenzhen, Trump stated that he wished to discuss bringing it to an end. The issue of Ukraine was also addressed during his separate meeting with Putin.

This suggests that the public discussion extended beyond what had been anticipated, though there is no evidence that an understanding on the terms for peace was reached—which, in a way, also explains why Ukraine is not mentioned in the joint statement. For Kyiv, this concern is understandable. Discussing a country’s future without its own representatives creates uncertainty about the weight that will be given to its own will. At the same time, American envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner have signalled upcoming talks with Ukraine and European partners in Berlin, aimed at aligning positions on a potential peace agreement. This indicates that diplomacy continues beyond the discussions held in Shenzhen.

For Europe, the way these various channels are connected will be significant. Consultation with allies should influence the substance of the negotiations. If such consultation serves merely to inform allies after other understandings have already been reached, it raises questions about the level of trust—or lack thereof—within the transatlantic relationship. An agreement that requires European support for its implementation necessitates Europe’s involvement during its drafting. Furthermore, any comparison to a “new Yalta” should be approached with caution. Based on the information made public—as well as the joint statement itself—there is no indication of an agreement to divide spheres of influence. However, the sight of three powers discussing their special responsibility for the world raises concerns for countries that rely on adherence to international rules.

For these nations, security cannot rest solely on the mutual understanding reached during a meeting between presidents. This highlights a broader issue in international relations: while power grants states the ability to influence others, it does not automatically confer the right to make decisions on their behalf. A diplomatic process becomes more stable when the countries affected have reason to accept the outcome.

NUCLEAR WEAPONS REMAIN THE MOST DIFFICULT HURDLE

As the world’s three largest nuclear powers, the United States, Russia, and China are uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth, as well as how to lower the risk that such weapons might ever be used.

Trump raised the issue of nuclear arms reduction and offered a concrete proposal, while simultaneously acknowledging the difficulty of relinquishing such arsenals, remarking that giving up nuclear weapons is “a very hard thing to do.” Xi reiterated his stance in favour of a world free of nuclear weapons and emphasised the need to avoid nuclear war. However, the disparity in arsenals also remains a fundamental obstacle. The US and Russia possess stockpiles far larger than China’s. Washington seeks to include Beijing within a new framework, yet China has little incentive to accept obligations that could place it at a disadvantage vis-à-vis the other two powers.

THE ECONOMY AWAITS GREATER CLARITY

In the economic sphere, a distinction must be made between the trilateral summit and the meeting between Trump and Xi. US-China trade issues are subject to their own separate negotiations. Trump pushed for increased Chinese purchases of American agricultural products, while the discussions took place against the backdrop of a relationship in which the fulfilment of prior commitments remains a source of friction. Reports immediately following the summit did not indicate any new, detailed trade package that could be attributed to a collective outcome involving all three presidents.

For businesses, the continuation of contact is beneficial. Nevertheless, investments require a more predictable outlook than the mere declaration of a “good relationship” at a conference. A company reliant on Chinese supplies needs to know whether it will be granted an export licence. An American farmer needs to see concrete orders. Without such certainty, the cost of waiting continues to weigh on the economy. Credibility would be established through the implementation of consistent rules. However, there is a limit to what trade can resolve. When a technology is viewed as critical to national security, economic gain is not enough to persuade a government to lift restrictions. Therefore, an improvement in trade relations can coexist with intense competition in strategic sectors. Companies will need to account for this dichotomy in their long-term decision-making. Financial markets do not subsist on summit news alone. From a market perspective, the most prudent conclusion is that the Shenzhen meeting has not yet provided a basis for declaring a major economic shift. Reports from the European morning session indicated that investors were still awaiting details from the meeting. Meanwhile, the dollar was influenced by expectations regarding U.S. interest rates, while the oil market weighed supply prospects against risks to shipping in the Persian Gulf.

If enthusiasm is not matched by concrete changes, the financial impact could dissipate just as quickly as it emerged. The situation involving Iran remains of direct economic significance. The security of passage through the Strait of Hormuz affects shipping costs and energy expectations. Trump stated that he and Xi shared a common interest in keeping the strait open.

Regarding Russia, too, a distinction must be made between a diplomatic rapprochement and a change in economic conditions. A warmer relationship with Washington does not mean that banks could immediately resume activities restricted by sanctions. Companies require clear legal changes before they are willing to take on new risks. European measures depend on decisions made by European institutions, which makes the EU’s involvement significant—including with regard to the financial aspects of any future agreement. What will make the meeting more credible? The real test will come once the leaders have left Shenzhen.

*Academician Prof. Dr Anastas Angjeli is an economy expert, former MP and Economy Minister, founder and President of the Mediterranean University of Albania